The Book Radar Logo.
Back to Book
Review
Boys in the Valley cover
4.00 avg
1 reviews
335 pages
2023
Fiction
Horror
Cat T
February 3, 2026
Rating
4.0
Phew, this book...!

I'd seen this EVERYWHERE when I was lucky enough to be sent an advance copy. The author was pleasant on social media, and I was looking forward to diving in. Even though I'd seen it compared to everything from 'The Exorcist' to 'Lord of the Flies', with effusive praise all over the place, I approached it as I always try to do - as a book in itself. A unique story.

Boy, is it that!

The tale starts gently... before quickly swerving. This isn't a nice, happy school that we're watching; it's a cold, winter religious school for unwanted boys, with priest/teachers ranging from good and decent to downright awful.

We meet the boys, learn their friendships and worries, see them work together against the adult world.

And then... it's all tipped on its head.

A difficult, isolated and lonely school is suddenly home to a very real demonic presence, with a group of men struggling in from the snowy woods nearby. Not quite 'The Thing', but that was in my mind. We quickly move into the part that others had noted as 'Exorcist'-like, but that's over relatively quickly.

Quietness resumes, if rather shaken. But of course, it's not.

This book takes its time introducing the characters and setting, because we're going to be trapped with them for the duration. The evil that arrives is truly monstrous, and the fact that this is a religious school (albeit with varying degrees of 'godly' perspectives) makes it somehow even worse as we watch everything fall.

This is horror. The real human world versus what seems almost inevitable downfall. Before I knew it, I found myself going from passive observer/reader to actively rooting for the boys to come through intact - which of course, they won't. Edge of seat stuff.

If it reminded me of anything, it was the graphic novels of John Constantine. Constant hope in the face of imminent supernatural, unknowable doom. We have to hope and battle, or what chance do we have?

Very much a heart-pounding read, and worthy of its recommendations.
Be the first to start a conversation about this review.
Report

Let us know what’s wrong.

Additional info
Leaving The Book Radar

You are about to visit an external website:

Please verify this is a trusted source before continuing. The Book Radar is not responsible for external content.